Trending
Advertise with us →

News

Autonomous weapons talks leave binding rules undecided

2 min read
AI-generated illustration of a closed navy folder and a small faceted metal component on an ivory desk

States at UN talks in Geneva have agreed to develop an instrument on lethal autonomous weapons over the next two years, while leaving open whether the eventual rules will be legally binding. The outcome was announced on Saturday 21 November by Switzerland’s foreign ministry.

The agreement followed a week of discussions at the Seventh Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons. Switzerland said the convention’s 128 states had agreed to work on the instrument during 2027 and 2028, with its legal form to be specified after negotiations conclude.

A mandate with an unresolved question

The Swiss account described the outcome as progress after more than a decade of discussions. It also acknowledged that the consensus-based conference had been unable to agree immediately on a mandate for a legally binding instrument, despite support from a majority of states.

NPR’s reporting from Geneva described a compromise reached after negotiations continued into the early hours of Saturday. It reported disappointment among humanitarian organisations and countries that had wanted a faster route to binding rules. Before the conference, the International Committee of the Red Cross had called for such rules to be drafted within a year.

In its statement on Saturday, the ICRC regretted the failure to secure a clear and immediate negotiating mandate for a binding instrument. It renewed its appeal for a treaty that would prohibit unpredictable autonomous weapons and those targeting people directly, while placing restrictions on other systems. Those are the organisation’s demands for future rules, rather than prohibitions adopted at this conference.

What the debate covers

The ICRC’s October background guidance describes autonomous weapons as systems that, once activated, can select targets and apply force without further human intervention. It also states that existing international humanitarian law already applies to them. The unresolved treaty question does not mean these weapons sit outside the laws governing armed conflict.

The UN’s pre-conference explainer identifies accountability and the extent of human control as central issues. It says the Group of Governmental Experts brings together government representatives, military specialists, lawyers, researchers and civil society to develop recommendations. Its September findings included possible provisions on human responsibility for force and compliance with international law.

Cover: AI-generated illustration of a folder and an abstract metal component, not a weapon or conference document.

Posted by Published on Filed under News

Comments are disabled.